The influenza vaccination debate
With public health emergencies recently declared in boston and new york state, the flu isn't just hitting patients this season it's hurting hospital-clinician relations after the h1n1 outbreak. The cdc reports that pneumonia can be caused by the chickenpox vaccine, and a small possibility exists that the flu vaccine could be associated with guillain-barré syndrome, a disorder in which the person’s immune system attacks parts of the peripheral nervous system, in about one or two per million people vaccinated debate topics. That's how rajesh prabhu, md, an infectious disease specialist and the chief patient safety officer with essentia health of duluth, minn, explained the company's decision to mandate that all healthcare employees, staff, and volunteers get the seasonal flu vaccine this year, a decision that led to dozens being fired. The vaccine debate a public health expert explains why some children remain unvaccinated and why that puts all children's health at risk. Autism and the vaccine debate the debate over whether or not vaccines contribute to the development of autism is far from settled many families insist that their child developed normally, but then regressed into autism after receiving routine immunizations.
Debate, analyse arguments for and against mandatory vaccination policies, and consider the principles and virtues of clinical, professional, institutional and pub- evidence that hcw influenza vaccination affects the outcome of elderly residents (aged 60 years or older)  hcw influenza vaccination has been shown to. The flu vaccine and working in health care: the debate just after the november 2012 elections we heard a rumor about potential legislation that was troubling: the bill would bar private businesses from requiring that employees get the flu vaccine, even if the business involved is health care-centered. There is much ongoing debate about the need for mandatory approaches to increase rates of immunization against seasonal influenza among health care providers. The exact magnitude of the benefit of influenza vaccine among elderly individuals is subject of considerable debated existing vaccine effectiveness estimates come mostly from observational studies, which may be biased because of difficulties in identifying and adjusting for confounders.
Essay on the influenza vaccination debate - mandatory influenza vaccinations for healthcare providers can be a controversial topic for some and may propose a challenge to some provider’s ethical values and beliefs. Top 10 reasons to skip the flu shot posted by: lori alton, staff writer in vaccine dangers november 15, 2015 11 comments ( naturalhealth365 ) as surely as the calendar signals the change of seasons, the annual onslaught of warnings to get the flu shot comes around each and every fall. The debate on mandatory vaccines for healthcare workers in an effort to protect patients from communicable diseases, us hospitals are compelling health care workers to get vaccinated against the flu and other infectious diseases. Getting rid of egg-based flu vaccines may be easier said than done, but it may be more of a long-term solution than anything that will happen in the short-term.
The debate over mandatory flu vaccines for nurses posted on april 22, 2015 august 31, 2018 just before the current flu season started last fall, the massachusetts nurses association sued brigham and women’s hospital over a new policy that made the flu vaccine mandatory for nurses as a condition of employment – in other words, nurses who. Some vaccines cause a temporary headache, fatigue or loss of appetite rarely, a child might experience a severe allergic reaction or a neurological side effect, such as a seizure although these rare side effects are a concern, the risk of a vaccine causing serious harm or death is extremely small. As of january 1, 2017, iac no longer maintains its journal articles web section please visit the federal government's pubmed website to access a complete listing of journal articles pubmed website to access a complete listing of journal articles. The clinical manifestations and diagnosis of influenza in adults, the role of antiviral agents for the prevention and treatment of seasonal influenza, and vaccines against h5n1 and h7n9 avian influenza are also reviewed elsewhere.
The debate over a swine flu shot is even reaching into some capitol hill offices, causing an internal debate over image “it is an image issue,” said sen sam brownback (r-kan. For example, years of scientific research, assembled by researcher judy wilyman, have demonstrated how ineffective the whooping cough vaccination really is, and why it is nothing short of madness to continue to claim that whooping cough vaccination will lead to a decline in this disease. To get a flu shot or not to get a flu shotthat is the question it's a medical debate that has been going on for years, and while the centers for disease control and prevention recommends that. The flu vaccine is recommended in 6 months and older there is debate in regards to the flu vaccine’s effectiveness and safety for pregnant women due to a “lack of evidence,” specifically in randomized controlled trials (rcts) the argument is that the data for recommendation usually comes from observational studies.
The influenza vaccination debate
Experts examine the issues and data associated with calls to mandate influenza vaccination for healthcare professionals. The flu vaccine isn't as effective as other vaccines according to the cdc, two doses of mumps vaccine are said to be 88 percent effective at preventing the illness one dose is 78 percent effective. Nosocomial transmission is well documented7 influenza infection control should include, in addition to vaccination, hand hygiene, isolation of infected patients, targeted masking, and leave of absence for healthcare workers with influenza-like illness8 vaccination is a keystone intervention, differing from others by reducing risk in all.
Vaccination pros and cons: the debate scientific research has consistently demonstrated the importance of immunization for example, the chicken pox, influenza and the human papiloma virus (hpv) vaccines have saved millions of people's lives. The national childhood vaccine injury act of 1986, acknowledged that vaccine injuries and deaths are real and that the vaccine injured and their families should be financially supported and that vaccine safety protections were needed in the mass vaccination system.
The ability of influenza vaccines to prevent influenza varies considerably, he says, citing a 9-year study from california where it protected a reported high of 93% to a low of 46% in 2012, vaccine effectiveness against the dominant a(h3n2) influenza was 47% in the us and 45% in canada (mmwr201362:119-23. Flu season is here, and once again the question arises as to whether or not flu vaccinations should be mandatory for health care workers the advisory committee on immunization practices recommends that all healthcare workers get the vaccination in order to protect both themselves and the patients with whom they come into contact. The articles are in a debate format, with dr schabas arguing in favour of massive flu vaccination, while dr demicheli offers convincing arguments and statistics that question the effectiveness of such a massive expenditure on a program that cannot be proven to be effective.